Crucial Minutia
it's the little things...
google
yahoo
bing
Kate Torgovnick
Bono Invades the Times
7 Comments | posted January 12th, 2009 at 09:47 am by Kate Torgovnick

bonoThose opening the Opinion pages of The New York Times yesterday were greeted with a strange surprise—Bono is the Times’ new columnist. You’d think to be a Times columnist, you’d have to (a) have a last name and (b) take off your sunglasses for your columnist photo, but apparently, neither is the case. The topic of his first column? Frank Sinatra and New Years’ Eve—the kind of piece most columnists wait a few weeks to do, when they’re at a total loss for real things to write about.

Now, I actually like Bono. I do. But his writing is, well, not good. He does what many non-writers do when they’re told to write—he overdoses on flowery language and packs in as many adverbs and gerunds as he can in a sentence. A sample:

“Glasses clinking clicking, clashing crashing in Gaelic revelry: swinging doors, sweethearts falling in and out of the season’s blessings, family feuds subsumed or resumed. Malt joy and ginger despair are all in the queue to be served on this, the quarter-of-a-millennium mark since Arthur Guinness first put velvety blackness in a pint glass.”

Velvety blackness? Ugh.

So here is my advice to Bono. One, pick topics that really matter to you. After all, weren’t you nominated for a Nobel Peace Prize? Don’t you want to inform the general public about bad things going on around the world? And two, keep it simple. “Nothing changes New Years’ Day”—that was great. Those five little words had way more impact than this entire column. And finally, take off the sunglasses. Really, dude. —Kate

This entry was posted on Monday, January 12th, 2009 at 9:47 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

There are currently 7 responses

  1. Juanita

    Damn. That is depressing. It’s curious: writers never tell engineers, “oh, sure I could build that bridge,” or “yeah, I build bridges on the weekends sometimes,” but a whole lot of tin-eared non-writers will tell you–even though they rarely read a book!–that they are writers.

    January 12th, 2009 | 11:24 am
  2. Wow. Kate, I love the idea of you setting Bono straight. Heck, we know some people at the Times op-ed pages read our blog (C.S., ahem, C.S.). Maybe they’ll pass this on to him..

    The sunglasses are ridiculous.

    January 13th, 2009 | 9:44 am
  3. LOL! Yes, yes, yes. As Truman Capote said, “That’s not writing, that’s typing.”

    Knowing how to use Word doesn’t make him a writer, and the fact that I sing in the shower doesn’t make me anyone’s idea of a lead singer.

    Deborah ;)

    January 13th, 2009 | 11:51 pm
  4. ok. i’m going to take the unpopular side here. and full disclosure: i effing love bono, so part of me actually thinks he can do whatever he wants because he’s bono. (including wear sunglasses indoors and/or in author photos). and while i won’t defend “malt joy and velvety despair,” it is his *first* piece. which leaves plenty of room for growth. i mean the guy wrote, “one.” i’m willing to stick around for a few more columns.

    January 14th, 2009 | 12:11 am
  5. Wow. Not your typical column, no. Here’s what I’m thinking though– if we heard it in Bono’s entrancing voice with The Edge’s guitar under it, might it not just be beautiful?

    He’s been writing lyrics for 30 years, so it may take some time to switch to an editorial style– if he even wants to. Excellent tip to suggest that he write about what’s going on in the world today.

    January 14th, 2009 | 10:05 am
  6. Joie Jager-Hyman

    Have to agree with Kate on this one. Sometimes it’s better to stick to the genre that you’re good at until you earn your stripes. Wonder what a Paul Krugman ballad would sound like or some Maureen Dowd hip-hop. My money is on NOT GOOD.

    January 14th, 2009 | 3:20 pm
  7. Kate Torgovnick

    Maureen Dowd hip hop. HA! I would pay to see that.

    And I do think you’re right, Felice and Cristina. Bono writes amazing lyrics. So maybe he’ll get the hang of writing opinion pieces. Maybe in a year, we’ll look back at this column and laugh.

    And the Edge can wear sunglasses any day.

    January 14th, 2009 | 8:03 pm